Is your case stuck in administrative process? We can help you by completing this form.

Blind Man Failed U.S. Citizenship Test because it Wasn't Offered in Braille

Spread the love

Lucio Delgado was born 100% blind in Mexico.

He became a legal permanent resident in the U.S. six years ago after coming to the United States as a teenager, and learned English by listening in school and on the radio.

Lucio and his family received green cards to escape fear of local drug cartels in Mexico.

He practiced civics questions for the citizenship test, and even went to an optometrist to get a vision exam and prove he was legally blind. Because of this, he asked in his citizenship application to be given his citizenship test in Braille, a system of raised dots that can be read with fingers for blind people.

On May 21, Delgado showed up to his citizenship test. The civics portion was oral, and he passed through that portion of the test. But then the reading portion of the test came.

The USCIS agent said they received his request for a Braille test, but USCIS did not have a Braille test available. They only had large print.

"I don't read large print" he said. "I'm totally blind."

Still, the officer had to give him three attempts to read a sentence. However, Delgado was blind and couldn't read what he couldn't see.

The agent mentioned that he should come back to USCIS for a second interview later so the agents could waive the reading portion of the test, but only if he visited an ophthalmologist, an eye doctor who specializes in testing and diagnosing blindness. The letter he received from the optometrist didn't matter.

However, Delgado doesn't have health insurance, and he couldn't afford to see the specialist.

Late last month, Delgado received a letter from USCIS. "Unfortunately, you were unable to read a sentence in the English language. Regrettably, you were unable to achieve a passing score on the reading portion of the naturalization test," it said, letting him know that his naturalization was denied.

"I really wasn't expecting not to be provided that very basic accommodation," he said. "It was quite a shocker, really."

USCIS has been working on fixing the barriers for disabled immigrants wanting to obtain citizenship for years, but it wasn't happening.

A few months after Delgado's test, USCIS announced that they would begin offering the test in Braille to blind applicants.

Delgados attorney has commented on the agent asking him to see a ophthalmologist, saying, "The Americans with Disabilities Act itself does not require diagnosis by a medical doctor. Can a public agency decide that's the criteria it wants to adopt? I suppose so, but only to the point that it does not become a barrier. For Lucio, it was definitely a barrier."

She also said that making Delgado visit the specialist after he already went to an optometrist for an eye exam seemed to be unnecessary. Delgado’s eyes are clouded over, and he uses a white cane to get around. His disability should have been obvious.

After his story became widespread news, USCIS contacted Delgado and has scheduled another appointment with him for later this week.

 

You May Also Like

A Complete Guide To The U.S. Naturalization Test And Interview Spread the love Becoming a U.S. citizen is an exciting and life-changing journey. One of the key steps in this process is taking the naturalization test. This test, administered... VIEW POST
Can You Apply for Naturalization with an Expired Green Card? Spread the love A green card, known as a Permanent Resident Card, serves as evidence of your legal permanent resident status in the US. It allows you to work... VIEW POST
April 2024 USCIS Fees Increase: What You Need To Know Spread the love The United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has announced a significant increase in fees for various immigration applications and services. This move has sparked concerns... VIEW POST

Download Free Guide 
2024 Immigrant’s Guide to 
Becoming a U.S. Citizen

This guide contains all you need to know to become  
a U.S. citizen.

Download Free Guide 2022 Immigrant’s Guide to Becoming a U.S. Citizen

This guide contains all you need to know
to become a U.S. citizen.
DOWNLOAD FREE PDF

Immigration 
Answers Show
Live every week.

JOIN US