Is your case stuck in administrative process? We can help you by completing this form.

Federal Appeals Court in St. Louis Denies Bosnian Asylum Claim

Spread the love

The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the denial of a Bosnian couple's claim that they had a credible fear of persecution if they returned to their native homeland.  Hazret and Jasminka Nanic entered the U.S. in November of 2006.  Customs gave them until June 8, 2007 to depart the U.S.  They did not leave; instead, they filed asylum petitions on June 13, 2007.  The couple also requested the discretionary relief of withholding of removal, as well as protection under the Convention Against Torture ("CAT").  The asylum office denied the claim and referred the case to the immigration court.

In asylum cases, one of the strongest pieces of evidence of future persecution is, in fact, instances of prior persecution.  The Nanics told the immigration judge about being harassed by a police officer in 1994, being hit by the police in 1996 and some harassment that their daughters had suffered in 1996.   The immigration judge did not find these decade old, relatively minor instances to constitute past persecution.  The asylum, withholding and CAT claims were denied.

The Board of Immigration Appeals upheld the denial and the Nanics appealed to the Eighth Circuit in St. Louis.  As it turns out, the Eighth Circuit is one of the least immigrant-friendly courts in the entire nation.  The Court very rarely rules in favor of the immigrant and against the Department of Homeland Security.  True to form, the Court denied the claims and upheld the decision of the Board of Immigration Appeals.  In doing so, the Court agreed with the lower court findings that the past harassment did not constitute persecution.  The Court also rejected the Nanics' claim that they faced persecution for yet another reason - their refusal to identify as a Serb, Croat or Muslim and to instead state their support for a unified Bosnia.

This was a tough case.  Life in Bosnia has returned to some semblance of normality since the brutal civil war of the late 1990s.  It seems that this case had very little chance of success, given the thin evidence of harassment that the couple provided.  It also highlights just how hard it is for immigrants to succeed at the Eighth Circuit.


You May Also Like

How Do You Sponsor An Immigrant: A Step-By-Step Guide Spread the love Image Source: USCIS Immigration sponsorship is a vital and often complex process that plays a pivotal role in foreign nationals aiming to live or work in... VIEW POST
Everything You Need to Know About H1B Premium Processing Fee Spread the love The H1B visa is a nonimmigrant visa allowing American employers to hire foreign workers in special positions for a certain period. Specialty occupations usually need a... VIEW POST
Form I-90 Filing Fee Breakdown: Renewing or Replacing Your Green Card Spread the love If you’re a lawful permanent resident (LPR) of the United States, you’re given a green card, also known as a permanent resident card. This legal document... VIEW POST

Download Free Guide 
2024 Immigrant’s Guide to 
Becoming a U.S. Citizen

This guide contains all you need to know to become  
a U.S. citizen.

Download Free Guide 2022 Immigrant’s Guide to Becoming a U.S. Citizen

This guide contains all you need to know
to become a U.S. citizen.

Answers Show
Live every week.